Why Water Utility Debt Is Exposed to the Forest Upstream

Why Utility Debt Is Exposed to the Forest Upstream

Written by: Zach Knight, Blue Forest CEO & Co-founder

When I worked in securitization, an asset losing value faster than its financing assumed was the kind of thing that kept people up at night. Sediment is eating into reservoir capacity, turning some reservoirs into exactly that kind of asset.

Sediment hits water utilities in two places: it takes up storage, and when it reaches treatment plants, it makes water more expensive and challenging to treat. Recent research led by Abigail Eckland and Melissa Foster modeling more than 57,000 U.S. reservoirs estimates they’ve collectively lost about 8% of their original storage, and more than two in five have lost over a quarter. Severe fire upstream can add to this by sending soil off burned slopes and into reservoirs, so a single fire can both shrink a utility’s storage and raise its operating costs.

Some of the largest U.S. reservoirs were built in a construction boom that peaked in the 50s through 70s, with room set aside for about a century’s worth of sediment. Many are already more than halfway through that century, and we aren’t building more storage.

Many of the utilities that depend on these reservoirs finance their infrastructure with bonds repaid from customers’ water bills, so lost storage and rising treatment costs eventually show up in what customers pay and in the credit bondholders rely on. In securitization, you’d look at what an asset’s performance depends on. For a reservoir downstream of a forest, that performance is linked to the forest’s health. If you hold utility debt, you’re already exposed to the condition of that forest, whether or not anyone has priced it in. And many of those forests are overgrown and at risk of the kind of severe fire that sends sediment downstream.

But you can’t price in the benefits of a healthy watershed unless you have a way of measuring them, which has been a focus of our Science team since the earliest days of Blue Forest. In the early years we focused more on quantifying how improving forest conditions can increase water supply. Sediment’s cost, including lost reservoir storage and harder-to-treat water, have received less attention in conservation finance. With Wren Raming joining us last year, our team now models reservoir sedimentation and water quality, giving a fuller picture of what restoration could be worth to a utility.

Blue Forest’s Forest Resilience Bond investors provide capital up front, so time-sensitive restoration can start when the forest needs it instead of waiting on public funding, and they’re repaid over time as government grants reimburse costs. Combined with what utilities contribute, that capital pays for restoration aimed at reducing the risk of severe fire upstream, making it, in effect, maintenance on both kinds of storage: the watershed above, where snowpack and meadows hold water and release it slowly, and the reservoir below.

See here for research coverage from Kaleb Roedel.